Welcome to Brothers BBQ NY
At Brothers BBQ NY, culinary passion meets Southern charm. Nestled in New Windsor, this soul food spot serves up mouthwatering barbecue that leaves patrons craving more. With a diverse menu featuring tender brisket, flavorful smoked wings, and hearty burgers, the flavors are bold and satisfying. The warm, welcoming atmosphere makes it ideal for families and groups, while outdoor seating enhances the experience. Their attentive service and happy hour specials create a relaxed environment. Brothers BBQ NY is not just a restaurant; it's a community hub where every meal feels like a family gathering. Savor the soul of barbecue at this beloved eatery!
Brothers BBQ NY: Reviews & Ratings
Heres the short version There is nowhere I could recommend higher, and words are not enough to describe the amazing experience. ...
Amanda was my waitress, and she was very sweet and kind. We actually share the same name. She did a phenomenal job at making me and my kids feel comfortable. I will be coming back and would like her again. Thanks again for making this a great experience.
I lived in Austin for a year and the only thing I missed when I returned to the triState was their barbecue. We literally drive 1.5 hours to get here. One way. Past innumerable barbecue ...
This past weekend had a great meal at Brothers barbecue. Its me and my familys first time eating here and I could truly say it was a great straightforward experience. Staff are friendly and welcome us when we came in. We were seated right ...
Do whatever you have to do to come try this barbeque spot. It is amazing. Stopped in on the way through town with my own brothers and we are like kings. Burnt ends top class. Smoked wings top class. Brisket sandwich was amazing. Mac and ...
I took my husband here for lunch today for his birthday and I cant say enough of how good it was! The server was so amazing and sweet! The food was so delicious. I got to say I looked at the reviews before and we were a little nervous, the Mac and cheese was probably the best Mac and cheese I have ever had. We definitely will be back!
Whoa! So Im from Nebraska so Im always very apprehensive of any BBQ joints outside the general Midwest area as typically Im less than happy. Brothers BBQ is a hidden gem! ...
Came here for my birthday and was not disappointed! This was the best barbecue Ive had since visiting Texas. Our server, Amanda, was very kind and provided excellent service. I would definitely recommend!
Location
-
2402 NY-32, New Windsor, NY 12553 Hotline: (845) 534-4227
Welcome to Brothers BBQ NY, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of New Windsor, NY. This soul food caterer has quickly become a favorite for those who crave authentic and mouth-watering barbecue. As you arrive at 2402 NY-32, you’re greeted by a casual yet classy atmosphere—ideal for families, groups, or a casual lunch with friends.
Brothers BBQ NY stands out not only for its delicious offerings but also for its inviting ambiance. The establishment is wheelchair accessible, dog-friendly, and provides outdoor seating. They also accept various payment methods, including Apple Pay, making it convenient for everyone. With a comprehensive menu that encapsulates the essence of Southern barbecue, you’ll find dishes that honor tradition while satisfying modern cravings.
- Smoked Yard Bird: A half chicken brined for 12 hours, expertly smoked until tender and juicy.
- Pulled Pork Plate: Hand-pulled to order, this dish embodies the tenderness and flavor you expect from a great BBQ.
- Chopped BBQ Plate: A North Carolina staple, this smoked pork is dressed with a distinctive vinegar-based sauce that adds a kick.
- Burgers: Their classic 8oz blend burger can be customized with toppings and is served with crispy French fries—a must-try!
The reviews from satisfied customers echo the sentiments of a true barbecue lover. One patron, Sábado G., exclaimed, “There is nowhere I could recommend higher,” capturing the essence of the experience at Brothers BBQ NY. Others shared their joy over the friendly staff, cozy environment, and of course, the delectable food that keeps them coming back for more.
Notably, the high praises from diners such as Jenn E. reveal that people are willing to make significant trips, even 1.5 hours, just to indulge in the incredible barbecue that Brothers BBQ NY has to offer. In a world filled with dining options, finding a spot like this—where flavors are bold, service is warm, and memories are made—is truly special.
As you plan your visit, don't forget to take advantage of the happy hour specials and enjoy a drink from their full bar, adding to the overall experience. Whether you're looking for lunch, dinner, or a casual meal with kids, Brothers BBQ NY has something for everyone. Come for the food, stay for the experience—your taste buds will thank you!
For reservations or more information, feel free to call (845) 534-4227. We can't wait to see you at Brothers BBQ NY!
